Sorry for the lack of activity on my blog recently. Work has alternated between super-busy and very slow, and in the latter times, I try to catch up on family stuff, my son’s college search, baking, sleep…things like that.
The Ridgewood Board of Ed meets tonight at 7:30, and I’ll be watching on FiOS Channel 33. One of the primary topics of interest is the Board’s decision about what to do with the aid that will be coming back to the District from the state. Governor Christie’s people are making a big deal about how this aid represents the governor’s “commitment to education,” but I can’t help but wonder why, if he was so committed, he took it away in the first place. But that’s neither here nor there anymore. Now districts like Ridgewood need to figure out what to do with the money – within all the budgetary restrictions and rules imposed by the state. The biggest issue, that most people don’t understand, is that the money really should not be used for anything that will be an ongoing cost. For example, teachers or staff. Why? Because if you add staff now (like, to reduce class sizes in a grade or two replace a program that was cut), then when next year’s budget rolls around, we won’t be able to fund those salaries. The budget cap (which is really a tax levy cap) will prevent those positions from being funded, because they were not funded by this year’s tax levy. The state’s tax levy cap makes it impossible for districts to most effectively incorporate a windfall-type infusion of funding. Just another unforeseen drawback that taxpayers don’t always see.
(I hope Governor Christie and his minions don't think this return of part of our funding makes up for the delay in reimbursing us for the referendum construction grant monies. Boy, the shell games they play...maybe we'll have to use the state aid money to pay for the construction, while we wait again for the state to fulfill its legal obligation...again.)
I’m not sure what the other options and restrictions are for these funds coming back from the state. Presumably, the funds could be placed in the district’s surplus account for now, and then applied according to the rules that guide that line item’s use. I presume that Dr. Fishbein will make a recommendation, or a couple of recommendations, to the Board as to how he thinks the funds should best be used. I’ll be interested in that conversation tonight.
I see from the agenda that there’s opportunity for public comment regarding the district’s alternatives, so if you have an opinion, please go to the Ed Center and share it.
Also on the agenda: a proposal by Dr. Fishbein to have the District reimburse BOE members for the cost of their state-mandated criminal history checks. I don’t know what these background checks are going to cost, yet, but I think it’s reasonable for the District to pick up the tab. (Frankly, I think Trenton should pick-up the tab.)
I also see that the Board will have the second reading of new and revised policies, one of which is the Extracurricular Code of Conduct policy which I think is confusing and problematic with regard to enforcement. Will be interested to see if there is any discussion.
I’m going to try and start posting more regularly again…I have been reading all the education news and info blogs I’ve always followed, just haven’t felt the need to talk much these days. I’ll be visiting colleges the rest of this week with my son, but feel free to send your comments, especially after tonight’s discussion/decision re: additional funding. Let me know what you think!
P.S. Sorry there are no links to the agenda, etc. For some reason Blogger is no allowing me to post links. Just one more reason I'm considering moving to another blog platform...
Welcome!
Welcome to Laurie Goodman's blog. I use this space to share news and opinions about education and schools in Ridgewood, the state of New Jersey and the nation, in addition to other issues I'm personally interested in. I invite you to share your thoughts, feelings, questions or opinions, too, by posting comments on any blog entry. Please observe basic courtesy -- keep your comments focused on issues, no personal attacks or bullying, please. Contact me directly at: lauriegood@mac.com
Showing posts with label trenton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trenton. Show all posts
Monday, July 18, 2011
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Improving the ability to survey students.
Today the NJ Senate Education Committee is holding a hearing on a bill, S-1696/A-3242, which will change (slightly) the way that schools secure parent permission to survey students. Sort of surprising that word of this bill is just now reaching Ridgewood, since the current law was inspired by the infamous Ridgewood survey of 1999. And surprising, too, (encouraging!) that some lawmakers have the good sense to bring this issue forward. The current law seriously undermines the ability of a community to collect data on issues that affect our students and to appropriately and locally develop solutions to keep our children safe and healthy.
The bill would allow students to participate in a voluntary survey if the district sends prior written notification to the student's parents, and the parent does not object. This is known as “passive consent” and the important word to note is consent. This bill does not “ignore” or “take away” parents’ rights. Parents absolutely have the right to prohibit their child from participating in a survey. In fact, some argue that passive consent maintains that option with increased anonymity.
Why is this bill important? Information about youth use of alcohol and drugs is used by a community, and the state, to develop effective prevention programs. In comparing the participation rate and cost of conducting a survey as proposed in this bill versus the current law, the NJ Department of Health and Senior Services found the cost of implementing a survey would be $1.80 per student versus $16.97 per student - nearly 10 times the cost. The overall average response rate was 91% versus 42%. As anybody who understands statistics knows, the higher the participation rate, the more meaningful and useful the data. Under the current law, the DHSS has concluded that participation rates of 42% are not adequate to provide meaningful information about youth populations – not to mention that state agencies cannot afford to conduct statewide surveys if they cost 10 times more.
More and more, school districts are being charged with caring for more than simply the “book learning” of students. Schools – as a constant and consistent point of contact with youth – are expected, and in many ways legally required, to care for the whole child: education, social development, physical wellness, mental/emotional health, etc. Beyond schools, agencies such as the DHSS are certainly and directly responsible for physical and mental health of our youth. Making it more difficult to gather real information in order to do their jobs makes no sense. One of the tools both school districts and state agencies need is the ability to compile information related to youth trends regarding attitudes and use of alcohol and drugs. The best way to do this is via a voluntary and anonymous system that respects parental concerns about the material children are exposed to in surveys administered at New Jersey schools.
I’ll be following the progress of these bills and I’ll keep you posted. As you know, the New Jersey legislative process is unpredictable (at best), so who knows what will happen next, or when.
The bill would allow students to participate in a voluntary survey if the district sends prior written notification to the student's parents, and the parent does not object. This is known as “passive consent” and the important word to note is consent. This bill does not “ignore” or “take away” parents’ rights. Parents absolutely have the right to prohibit their child from participating in a survey. In fact, some argue that passive consent maintains that option with increased anonymity.
Why is this bill important? Information about youth use of alcohol and drugs is used by a community, and the state, to develop effective prevention programs. In comparing the participation rate and cost of conducting a survey as proposed in this bill versus the current law, the NJ Department of Health and Senior Services found the cost of implementing a survey would be $1.80 per student versus $16.97 per student - nearly 10 times the cost. The overall average response rate was 91% versus 42%. As anybody who understands statistics knows, the higher the participation rate, the more meaningful and useful the data. Under the current law, the DHSS has concluded that participation rates of 42% are not adequate to provide meaningful information about youth populations – not to mention that state agencies cannot afford to conduct statewide surveys if they cost 10 times more.
More and more, school districts are being charged with caring for more than simply the “book learning” of students. Schools – as a constant and consistent point of contact with youth – are expected, and in many ways legally required, to care for the whole child: education, social development, physical wellness, mental/emotional health, etc. Beyond schools, agencies such as the DHSS are certainly and directly responsible for physical and mental health of our youth. Making it more difficult to gather real information in order to do their jobs makes no sense. One of the tools both school districts and state agencies need is the ability to compile information related to youth trends regarding attitudes and use of alcohol and drugs. The best way to do this is via a voluntary and anonymous system that respects parental concerns about the material children are exposed to in surveys administered at New Jersey schools.
I’ll be following the progress of these bills and I’ll keep you posted. As you know, the New Jersey legislative process is unpredictable (at best), so who knows what will happen next, or when.
Monday, April 25, 2011
Residents sought for advocacy committee.
The Superintendent of Schools and Board of Education are launching an initiative to gather together residents interested in advocating for Ridgewood’s public education at the state level. The newly formed Legislative Advocacy Committee will officially kick off at the Education Center, 49 Cottage Place, on Tuesday, May 3, with an event featuring Lynne Strickland, Executive Director of the Garden State Coalition of Schools (of which Ridgewood is a member). Ms. Strickland will speak on the "state of the state" concerning legislation; will address school funding; and will provide practical tips for contacting legislators. BOE members on the committee are Michele Lenhard and Sheila Brogan. All interested residents are welcome to attend the meeting, which will be held on the 3rd floor from 7:30 to 8:30 p.m.
For more information, call Dr. Fishbein's office at 201-670-2700, ext. 10530, or e-mail dfishbein@ridgewood.k12.nj.us. (You do not need to contact anyone in order to attend the meeting -- just show up if you're interested.)
For more information, call Dr. Fishbein's office at 201-670-2700, ext. 10530, or e-mail dfishbein@ridgewood.k12.nj.us. (You do not need to contact anyone in order to attend the meeting -- just show up if you're interested.)
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
The myth of the “budget vote.”
Yes, it’s an intentionally provocative title, but I wanted to share a perspective that I’ve commented on before, especially when I hear Ridgewood residents arguing about the upcoming election and whether they plan to vote for or against "the budget."
In addition to electing members of the Board of Education*, on April 27 the ballot question will read:
Voters (whether they are taxpayers or not, by the way) are asked to approve the total amount of taxes, for the schools, to be levied via property taxes. That’s it. We are not voting for or against the budget – not voting on how that tax levy is spent, and not voting on how much is allocated to the various lines and cost centers.
Based on that understanding of the fact of the vote process, and with New Jersey’s government-mandated 2% cap on how much the tax levy is allowed to grow, I can understand the occasional argument from Trenton that the annual “budget vote” is unnecessary if a district’s budget is under the legal cap. Sure, the vote is a rare democratic access point between residents and the delivery of their money to the “public good,” and people do like to feel like they have a say in what happens with their hard-earned taxes. (Imagine if we could vote on the Federal budget…or the state budget…the mind reels at the prospect of TV ads bought by PACs and political parties.) But how much of a say is that vote in April?
If you think the school district should spend more money on this program or that program, your vote really doesn’t affect that. If you want the school district to hire this teacher or fire that administrator, your vote doesn’t affect that. If you think your vote will send a message to the teacher’s union, I’m not so sure how your vote would affect that. The only thing our vote does is decide how much money will be collected from all the taxpayers in Ridgewood and delivered to the school district. How the money is divvied up is proposed by the administrators and approved by the BOE…whom you elect to do so.
I understand how some can feel powerless…that the vote is sort of futile, because it’s already a done deal by the time it’s on the ballot. I happen to think that we can do a better job of ascertaining what residents think about the budget – before the annual school election. I’ve talked about creating opportunities for more citizen involvement, earlier in the process. Practically speaking, I’m not entirely sure how. Fact is, the budget is big and complicated and not really something that can be reduced to “sound bites” – despite the public’s penchant for framing issues that way. Typical political polarization doesn’t really work on something this complex, with direct results on 5800+ individual students with individual needs, individual preferences and individual issues.
So, I just wanted to add a little education as to what you’re truly voting for or against on April 27. It's not "the budget." It's the proposed tax levy as indicated above. This tax levy reflects the lowest tax increase since the mid-1980s. It represents 0% total growth in the total budget, except health insurance, which we are estimating to rise 12%. (In fact, if it weren’t for the increase in health benefits, the budget would be going down $75,000.) And it keeps the education our children are currently receiving intact. A “yes” vote sets the tax rate. A “no” vote charges the Village Council with setting the tax rate. They don’t get to recommend cuts. They don’t order changes in spending on this vs. that. They just set the tax rate, presumably lower than what the Board asked for on the ballot.
However you feel about the tax levy, I hope you will get out and vote.
*Should probably mention again that I hope you will re-elect me to the Board. Our schools are facing the toughest time in their history. Rising costs, dwindling resources and increased regulations from the state have contributed to an environment where providing the quality education Ridgewood expects and deserves is more difficult than ever. I have worked hard for the past three years, and I believe I have so much more to give to our schools and our community.
In addition to electing members of the Board of Education*, on April 27 the ballot question will read:
Resolved, that there should be raised for the General Fund $81,323,178 for the ensuing school year (2011-2012).
Voters (whether they are taxpayers or not, by the way) are asked to approve the total amount of taxes, for the schools, to be levied via property taxes. That’s it. We are not voting for or against the budget – not voting on how that tax levy is spent, and not voting on how much is allocated to the various lines and cost centers.
Based on that understanding of the fact of the vote process, and with New Jersey’s government-mandated 2% cap on how much the tax levy is allowed to grow, I can understand the occasional argument from Trenton that the annual “budget vote” is unnecessary if a district’s budget is under the legal cap. Sure, the vote is a rare democratic access point between residents and the delivery of their money to the “public good,” and people do like to feel like they have a say in what happens with their hard-earned taxes. (Imagine if we could vote on the Federal budget…or the state budget…the mind reels at the prospect of TV ads bought by PACs and political parties.) But how much of a say is that vote in April?
If you think the school district should spend more money on this program or that program, your vote really doesn’t affect that. If you want the school district to hire this teacher or fire that administrator, your vote doesn’t affect that. If you think your vote will send a message to the teacher’s union, I’m not so sure how your vote would affect that. The only thing our vote does is decide how much money will be collected from all the taxpayers in Ridgewood and delivered to the school district. How the money is divvied up is proposed by the administrators and approved by the BOE…whom you elect to do so.
I understand how some can feel powerless…that the vote is sort of futile, because it’s already a done deal by the time it’s on the ballot. I happen to think that we can do a better job of ascertaining what residents think about the budget – before the annual school election. I’ve talked about creating opportunities for more citizen involvement, earlier in the process. Practically speaking, I’m not entirely sure how. Fact is, the budget is big and complicated and not really something that can be reduced to “sound bites” – despite the public’s penchant for framing issues that way. Typical political polarization doesn’t really work on something this complex, with direct results on 5800+ individual students with individual needs, individual preferences and individual issues.
So, I just wanted to add a little education as to what you’re truly voting for or against on April 27. It's not "the budget." It's the proposed tax levy as indicated above. This tax levy reflects the lowest tax increase since the mid-1980s. It represents 0% total growth in the total budget, except health insurance, which we are estimating to rise 12%. (In fact, if it weren’t for the increase in health benefits, the budget would be going down $75,000.) And it keeps the education our children are currently receiving intact. A “yes” vote sets the tax rate. A “no” vote charges the Village Council with setting the tax rate. They don’t get to recommend cuts. They don’t order changes in spending on this vs. that. They just set the tax rate, presumably lower than what the Board asked for on the ballot.
However you feel about the tax levy, I hope you will get out and vote.
*Should probably mention again that I hope you will re-elect me to the Board. Our schools are facing the toughest time in their history. Rising costs, dwindling resources and increased regulations from the state have contributed to an environment where providing the quality education Ridgewood expects and deserves is more difficult than ever. I have worked hard for the past three years, and I believe I have so much more to give to our schools and our community.
Thursday, April 14, 2011
Christie proposes education reform bills that would eliminate current tenure system for teachers.
This entire post is reprinted from NJ.com:
Gov. Chris Christie sent a package of education reform bills to the Legislature Wednesday that would eliminate tenure as teachers know it and offer job protection only to those who consistently show a high level of performance based on new statewide evaluation system.
Under the tenure proposal, teachers would be given one of four ratings — highly effective, effective, partially effective or ineffective — based equally on student performance and classroom observations. Acting Education Commissioner Christopher Cerf first unveiled the evaluation system during an address at Princeton University in February.
Teachers who receive the two highest ratings three years in a row would be eligible for tenure and merit pay, at their district’s discretion. Educators rated partially effective for two consecutive years or ineffective for one year — even if they have previously been highly rated — would lose tenure and could be fired.
"We want tenure to become something good teachers earn," said Christie, who has been advocating education reform for months. "It will not protect bad teachers who stay in front of the classroom.
"What we want is the most effective teachers at the front of every classroom regardless of seniority. Teachers who are effective are not worried about losing their jobs."
Under the current system, most teachers receive tenure after three years and one day on the job. The state has revoked tenure from just 17 teachers over the past 10 years. The process can drag out for years and be very costly to districts.
The tenure proposal is one of seven education reform bills Christie said he hopes will move through the Democrat-controlled Legislature quickly and be implemented by the 2012-13 school year.
Other proposals include:
None of the bills has a sponsor, leaving some legislators questioning the likelihood they will move forward at all.
Tom Hester Jr., a spokesman for the Assembly Democrats, said the caucus would review the bills and may introduce competing legislation.
Assembly Education Committee Chairman Patrick Diegnan (D-Middlesex) said he does not support any of the measures, as proposed, and would likely vote against them if they came before his committee.
"Everyone in education agrees that there are no reliable evaluation tools to accomplish what the governor continues to say should be the standard for hiring and retaining teachers," Diegnan said. "Test scores have been tried across the country and consistently produce unreliable results."
Steve Wollmer, a spokesman for the New Jersey Education Association, the state’s largest teachers union, said an evaluation system might drive performance in the corporate world, but won’t in the state’s public schools.
"You should not use standardized test scores to make high stakes personnel decisions," said Wollmer, whose union has consistently battled the governor over education reform. "There are too many factors that affect student test scores that teachers cannot control."
Adam Bauer, a spokesman for the Senate Republicans, said it is "highly likely" the bills will garner support — and sponsors — from the Republican caucus, including Senate Minority Leader Tom Kean Jr. (R-Union), who supports the governor’s education reform agenda.
"(Sen. Kean) looks forward to continuing to work with the administration on their shared commitment to saving kids from failing schools and measuring educational success based on outcomes," Bauer said.
Kean could not be reached for comment.
Lynne Strickland, executive director of the Garden State Coalition of Schools, a group of about 100 suburban districts, said Christie’s proposals will prompt "a real dialogue and conversation" about education reform in New Jersey.
She said a number of "stumbling blocks" from teachers’ perspectives, including the proposed changes to teacher compensation and the evaluation process based on assessment.
"The details in the legislation are going to be dramatically important," Strickland said. "That’s why it’s clear this is going to be hashed out. It should be, because this is significant change."
Click here to read original story and accompanying video and reader comments (always one of my favorite parts of any story!).
Gov. Chris Christie sent a package of education reform bills to the Legislature Wednesday that would eliminate tenure as teachers know it and offer job protection only to those who consistently show a high level of performance based on new statewide evaluation system.
Under the tenure proposal, teachers would be given one of four ratings — highly effective, effective, partially effective or ineffective — based equally on student performance and classroom observations. Acting Education Commissioner Christopher Cerf first unveiled the evaluation system during an address at Princeton University in February.
Teachers who receive the two highest ratings three years in a row would be eligible for tenure and merit pay, at their district’s discretion. Educators rated partially effective for two consecutive years or ineffective for one year — even if they have previously been highly rated — would lose tenure and could be fired.
"We want tenure to become something good teachers earn," said Christie, who has been advocating education reform for months. "It will not protect bad teachers who stay in front of the classroom.
"What we want is the most effective teachers at the front of every classroom regardless of seniority. Teachers who are effective are not worried about losing their jobs."
Under the current system, most teachers receive tenure after three years and one day on the job. The state has revoked tenure from just 17 teachers over the past 10 years. The process can drag out for years and be very costly to districts.
The tenure proposal is one of seven education reform bills Christie said he hopes will move through the Democrat-controlled Legislature quickly and be implemented by the 2012-13 school year.
Other proposals include:
• Ending the practice known as "last in, first out," which requires districts to lay off less experienced teachers first.
• Promoting what’s known as "mutual consent," which requires principals and teachers to agree on teachers’ assignments to schools.
• Offering bonuses to teachers who work in high needs districts and difficult to staff subject areas like math or science.
• Placing a 30-day deadline on tenure revocation decisions.
• Allowing school districts to opt out of the civil service system.
None of the bills has a sponsor, leaving some legislators questioning the likelihood they will move forward at all.
Tom Hester Jr., a spokesman for the Assembly Democrats, said the caucus would review the bills and may introduce competing legislation.
Assembly Education Committee Chairman Patrick Diegnan (D-Middlesex) said he does not support any of the measures, as proposed, and would likely vote against them if they came before his committee.
"Everyone in education agrees that there are no reliable evaluation tools to accomplish what the governor continues to say should be the standard for hiring and retaining teachers," Diegnan said. "Test scores have been tried across the country and consistently produce unreliable results."
Steve Wollmer, a spokesman for the New Jersey Education Association, the state’s largest teachers union, said an evaluation system might drive performance in the corporate world, but won’t in the state’s public schools.
"You should not use standardized test scores to make high stakes personnel decisions," said Wollmer, whose union has consistently battled the governor over education reform. "There are too many factors that affect student test scores that teachers cannot control."
Adam Bauer, a spokesman for the Senate Republicans, said it is "highly likely" the bills will garner support — and sponsors — from the Republican caucus, including Senate Minority Leader Tom Kean Jr. (R-Union), who supports the governor’s education reform agenda.
"(Sen. Kean) looks forward to continuing to work with the administration on their shared commitment to saving kids from failing schools and measuring educational success based on outcomes," Bauer said.
Kean could not be reached for comment.
Lynne Strickland, executive director of the Garden State Coalition of Schools, a group of about 100 suburban districts, said Christie’s proposals will prompt "a real dialogue and conversation" about education reform in New Jersey.
She said a number of "stumbling blocks" from teachers’ perspectives, including the proposed changes to teacher compensation and the evaluation process based on assessment.
"The details in the legislation are going to be dramatically important," Strickland said. "That’s why it’s clear this is going to be hashed out. It should be, because this is significant change."
Click here to read original story and accompanying video and reader comments (always one of my favorite parts of any story!).
Sunday, March 20, 2011
Governor Christie's inconsistent policy on salary caps lets charters use public funds to pay high salaries.
How is it fair that charter schools are exempt from Governor Christie's cap on superintendent salaries? If he truly wants to walk the walk and really believes that no one who runs a school district should make more than the governor, then how does he justify the exemption for charter schools? If he truly believes that what he calls high salaries are a misuse of public funds, how are charter schools -- also funded by public money -- allowed to pay their leaders more than the governor?
According to the story in today's Bergen Record:
According to the story in today's Bergen Record:
The director of a Teaneck charter school with about 300 students was paid more than $200,000 last year. In Englewood, the head of an even smaller charter school, with 200 students, earned $152,000 in public money for working part time.Only in New Jersey...
Governor Christie has moved to cap the salaries of superintendents at much larger traditional public school districts, but has proposed no such ceiling on tax-supported charters.
To some, the exemption shows how charters — publicly funded but independently operated — are given a pass when it comes to state regulations meant to ensure fiscal accountability.
"It's patently inequitable," said Bruce Baker, a Rutgers professor who has studied charter school financing.
Read the rest of the article here.
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
Should funds be taken from Ridgewood schools to pay for charters?
Today the New Jersey Left Behind blog questioned whether charter schools can serve a purpose in successful school districts. The writer was bothered by testimony at the charter school hearings in Trenton, at the Assembly Education Committee, where the school board president from Princeton argued that “regulations should require charter applicants to prove there was a true educational need for their new school, rather than just a desire for it among a select group of parents. She cautioned against the spread of “boutique” charters for studying Hebrew, Mandarin and “the extensive recycling of plastics.” Others made similar arguments.
The NJ Left Behind blogger commented, “In some ways this is a choice between philosophical inconsistency -- limiting school choice for some and not for others -- or the targeting of ed reform resources to those truly in need.”
I will not deny that having a choice of charter schools can be (although not always) a positive thing – in districts where the existing public schools are failing. But of course ed reform resources should be targeted “to those truly in need.” How could it be otherwise? That seems to make basic sense. The fear of high-performing districts is well-founded. If a charter wants to come into Ridgewood, why should our public school students have to give up successful programs in order to support it? Our district is high-performing. Our budget is stretched beyond the limit. We get $0 in state funding, and the 2% tax levy cap means we have to cut just to balance the budget. Our community already sends plenty of income tax dollars to Trenton, where it is redistributed to other districts. It simply would not be fair to siphon additional funds out of our schools, thereby affecting the quality, so that parents could set-up a “boutique” school, for something like Mandarin immersion. NJ Left Behind makes a good point with a quote from Ralph Waldo Emerson: “"a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." That sounds about right, especially when the “consistency” is at a level our community is not willing to accept.
The NJ Left Behind blogger commented, “In some ways this is a choice between philosophical inconsistency -- limiting school choice for some and not for others -- or the targeting of ed reform resources to those truly in need.”
I will not deny that having a choice of charter schools can be (although not always) a positive thing – in districts where the existing public schools are failing. But of course ed reform resources should be targeted “to those truly in need.” How could it be otherwise? That seems to make basic sense. The fear of high-performing districts is well-founded. If a charter wants to come into Ridgewood, why should our public school students have to give up successful programs in order to support it? Our district is high-performing. Our budget is stretched beyond the limit. We get $0 in state funding, and the 2% tax levy cap means we have to cut just to balance the budget. Our community already sends plenty of income tax dollars to Trenton, where it is redistributed to other districts. It simply would not be fair to siphon additional funds out of our schools, thereby affecting the quality, so that parents could set-up a “boutique” school, for something like Mandarin immersion. NJ Left Behind makes a good point with a quote from Ralph Waldo Emerson: “"a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." That sounds about right, especially when the “consistency” is at a level our community is not willing to accept.
Tuesday, November 9, 2010
New Jersey School Boards Association questions need for administrator salary caps.
From the most recent issue of School Board Notes:
Proposed salary caps for New Jersey superintendents and other central office school administrators are unnecessary and could prevent school boards from securing the best possible leaders for their education programs, according to NJSBA’s review of the proposal. The review took into account recent statute and regulations that have dramatically increased state oversight of local school district finances.
NJSBA President Ray Wiss will formally present the Association’s position to the state Department of Education on Nov. 18 during the first of four regional hearings on the proposal.
Unnecessary NJSBA supports certain aspects of the plan, including the concept of merit-based bonuses tied to educational goals and incentives for small school districts to share administrative services voluntarily. However, recent additions to state law and administrative code, such as the 2-percent property tax levy cap and the Accountability Regulations, render the proposed salary caps unnecessary.
“In practical terms, the new 2-percent tax levy cap, which is part of the governor’s toolkit to control government spending, coupled with reductions in state revenue make it financially imprudent for a school board to grant excessive compensation packages to administrators,” said Marie S. Bilik, NJSBA executive director. “Clearly, a school board that did so would have much to explain to its taxpayers and voters.
“In addition, the 2008 Accountability Regulations require all new contracts for central office administrators to receive approval from the state’s executive county superintendents. Such approval is granted only upon compliance with state-developed criteria that limit compensation, including benefits and salary increases.”
That review process is far-reaching and brings into question the need for rigid salary caps, according to NJSBA. In fact, Governor Christie relied on it last week when he instructed the executive county superintendents not to approve any superintendent contract extensions that exceed the salary caps and which would begin before the Feb. 7 effective date of the regulations.
Disadvantage “We share the goal of controlling the growth of all school district salaries and would consider reasonable constraints,” Bilik explained. “However, the limits proposed by the state might put some New Jersey school districts—especially those in areas with a high cost of living and which border other states—at a disadvantage when hiring superintendents and other administrators.”
When the proposed salary caps were introduced in the summer, NJSBA stressed that the role of the board of education is not to advocate for administrators’ salaries, but to ensure quality school leadership.
Low Administrative Costs Spending on school administration has not been a problem in New Jersey, according to federal statistics.
The latest report from the U.S. Department of Education places New Jersey’s overall spending on education administration below that of 42 other states. Compiled by the department’s National Center for Education Statistics, the data show that New Jersey public school districts devote 9.5 percent of their operating budgets to central office and school building administration, compared to a nationwide average of 10.8 percent. At the same time, the state’s spending on instruction and student support services (71.9 percent of total expenditures) is higher than the national average.
The Proposal The salary caps would be implemented through “commissioner regulations” as an amendment to the state’s Accountability Regulations without the need for approval by the state Board of Education.
Under the plan, salary caps would range from $125,000 for districts with fewer than 250 students, increasing incrementally to $175,000 for those with 6,501 to 10,000 students. Districts with more than 10,000 students would be able to apply for a waiver from the commissioner of education to exceed the top cap. The plan would also allow additional compensation in a district that operates a high school and for an individual who serves as superintendent for two or more districts. (A description of the proposal appeared in last week’s School Board Notes.)
Proposed salary caps for New Jersey superintendents and other central office school administrators are unnecessary and could prevent school boards from securing the best possible leaders for their education programs, according to NJSBA’s review of the proposal. The review took into account recent statute and regulations that have dramatically increased state oversight of local school district finances.
NJSBA President Ray Wiss will formally present the Association’s position to the state Department of Education on Nov. 18 during the first of four regional hearings on the proposal.
Unnecessary NJSBA supports certain aspects of the plan, including the concept of merit-based bonuses tied to educational goals and incentives for small school districts to share administrative services voluntarily. However, recent additions to state law and administrative code, such as the 2-percent property tax levy cap and the Accountability Regulations, render the proposed salary caps unnecessary.
“In practical terms, the new 2-percent tax levy cap, which is part of the governor’s toolkit to control government spending, coupled with reductions in state revenue make it financially imprudent for a school board to grant excessive compensation packages to administrators,” said Marie S. Bilik, NJSBA executive director. “Clearly, a school board that did so would have much to explain to its taxpayers and voters.
“In addition, the 2008 Accountability Regulations require all new contracts for central office administrators to receive approval from the state’s executive county superintendents. Such approval is granted only upon compliance with state-developed criteria that limit compensation, including benefits and salary increases.”
That review process is far-reaching and brings into question the need for rigid salary caps, according to NJSBA. In fact, Governor Christie relied on it last week when he instructed the executive county superintendents not to approve any superintendent contract extensions that exceed the salary caps and which would begin before the Feb. 7 effective date of the regulations.
Disadvantage “We share the goal of controlling the growth of all school district salaries and would consider reasonable constraints,” Bilik explained. “However, the limits proposed by the state might put some New Jersey school districts—especially those in areas with a high cost of living and which border other states—at a disadvantage when hiring superintendents and other administrators.”
When the proposed salary caps were introduced in the summer, NJSBA stressed that the role of the board of education is not to advocate for administrators’ salaries, but to ensure quality school leadership.
Low Administrative Costs Spending on school administration has not been a problem in New Jersey, according to federal statistics.
The latest report from the U.S. Department of Education places New Jersey’s overall spending on education administration below that of 42 other states. Compiled by the department’s National Center for Education Statistics, the data show that New Jersey public school districts devote 9.5 percent of their operating budgets to central office and school building administration, compared to a nationwide average of 10.8 percent. At the same time, the state’s spending on instruction and student support services (71.9 percent of total expenditures) is higher than the national average.
The Proposal The salary caps would be implemented through “commissioner regulations” as an amendment to the state’s Accountability Regulations without the need for approval by the state Board of Education.
Under the plan, salary caps would range from $125,000 for districts with fewer than 250 students, increasing incrementally to $175,000 for those with 6,501 to 10,000 students. Districts with more than 10,000 students would be able to apply for a waiver from the commissioner of education to exceed the top cap. The plan would also allow additional compensation in a district that operates a high school and for an individual who serves as superintendent for two or more districts. (A description of the proposal appeared in last week’s School Board Notes.)
Tuesday, September 21, 2010
Ridgewood to receive $98,000 in Federal money.
Well, we finally know the status of New Jersey's share of the Federal education jobs bill that was passed last month. Ridgewood is (of course) receiving one of the smaller allocations: $98,941 which can be spent on education jobs and related services. Trenton has not released any more detailed rules on how the funds can be spent, so the Ed Center hasn't made any decisions regarding how we'll use the funds. One thing to be mindful of -- since this is a one-time infusion of money, any position funded this year would not be funded next year -- without funds coming from elsewhere in the budget. Normally, when a district receives a one-time allocation of cash, it is wise to not use it for salaries or any expense that will be recurring. For example, supplies or repairs or something like that are usually safe. But in this case, the money is designed for jobs...which we will then be required to either fund again in subsequent years, or cut.
More details to come on where this money will be spent.
You can read the full story from NorthJersey.com by clicking here.
More details to come on where this money will be spent.
You can read the full story from NorthJersey.com by clicking here.
Friday, August 27, 2010
Breaking news: Governor Christie fires NJ Ed Commissioner Schundler
What a state we live in... No wonder the Federal government didn't trust New Jersey with millions of dollars in grants. Maybe if our state government could get its act together...
Published: Friday, August 27, 2010, 11:23 AM Updated: Friday, August 27, 2010, 11:28 AM
Josh Margolin/Statehouse Bureau
TRENTON - Gov. Chris Christie fired state education commissioner Bret Schundler this morning after Schundler refused to resign in the wake of the controversy over the state's loss of up to $400 million in federal school funding, two officials briefed on the situation said.
Christie's chief of staff, Richard Bagger, ordered Schundler to turn in his resignation Thursday night after federal officials released a video that appeared to contradict the commissioner's account of what transpired when the New Jersey delegation met with the federal officials to review funding application and review process.
By this morning Schundler had not quit, so Christie ordered his termination.
As education commissioner, Schundler was one of the highest profile members of the governor's cabinet. Governors can fire most cabinet members -- including the educational commissioner -- at will.
The controversy stemmed from the federal Race to the Top competitive grant program for education dollars. N.J. was seeking almost $400 million.
The Race to the Top application had asked for figures on state education funding from 2008 and 2009, but state officials provided figures for 2011. The oversight cost the state 4.8 critical points on a 500-point application. The state missed out on the grant by three points, placing 11th behind Ohio.
Christie originally blamed Washington bureaucrats at a Wednesday press conference, saying they refused to allow the state to fix a simple error in its application. But on Thursday, the U.S. Department of Education released video footage contradicting Christie's claim. The video shows state officials, headed by Schundler, struggling and failing to provide correct budget information during a 90-minute presentation.
In addition, a federal official said the state never provided the required information.
Published: Friday, August 27, 2010, 11:23 AM Updated: Friday, August 27, 2010, 11:28 AM
Josh Margolin/Statehouse Bureau
TRENTON - Gov. Chris Christie fired state education commissioner Bret Schundler this morning after Schundler refused to resign in the wake of the controversy over the state's loss of up to $400 million in federal school funding, two officials briefed on the situation said.
Christie's chief of staff, Richard Bagger, ordered Schundler to turn in his resignation Thursday night after federal officials released a video that appeared to contradict the commissioner's account of what transpired when the New Jersey delegation met with the federal officials to review funding application and review process.
By this morning Schundler had not quit, so Christie ordered his termination.
As education commissioner, Schundler was one of the highest profile members of the governor's cabinet. Governors can fire most cabinet members -- including the educational commissioner -- at will.
The controversy stemmed from the federal Race to the Top competitive grant program for education dollars. N.J. was seeking almost $400 million.
The Race to the Top application had asked for figures on state education funding from 2008 and 2009, but state officials provided figures for 2011. The oversight cost the state 4.8 critical points on a 500-point application. The state missed out on the grant by three points, placing 11th behind Ohio.
Christie originally blamed Washington bureaucrats at a Wednesday press conference, saying they refused to allow the state to fix a simple error in its application. But on Thursday, the U.S. Department of Education released video footage contradicting Christie's claim. The video shows state officials, headed by Schundler, struggling and failing to provide correct budget information during a 90-minute presentation.
In addition, a federal official said the state never provided the required information.
Tuesday, July 20, 2010
Ridgewood BOE opposes Governor Christie's proposed cap on superintendent salaries
Last night, the BOE passed a resolution opposing Governor Christie's proposed cap on superintendent's salaries. As I commented last night, I'm not sure such a resolution will do much good. It's largely symbolic. But I suppose it doesn't hurt anything either. Charlie Reilly discussed his view that Ridgewood is a leader among districts and that we should speak out about issues that we feel are unacceptable attacks on our district's ability to make decisions and represent our community's wishes. I see his point. I see Sheila Brogan's point that unlike the 2% budget cap, which is a done deal, there is still time to influence the Governor and/or legislature on the salary cap issue. I also see Michele Lenhard's point, that a resolution such as this should be part of a larger strategy, perhaps more coordinated with other districts or groups such as Garden State Coalition of Schools. In the end, I voted "yes," and will be interested to see if any other districts pass similar resolutions.
Here is the text of the resolution:
RESOLUTION OF THE RIDGEWOOD BOARD OF EDUCATION
RIDGEWOOD, NEW JERSEY
Superintendent Salary Cap
WHEREAS, on July 15, 2010, Governor Christopher Christie announced a reform proposal to cap school superintendents’ base pay; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie proposed that the capped salary be based on a sliding scale determined by the state; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal based the maximum amount of the capped salary for a superintendent on the number of students enrolled in the district; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal allows for an increment of $5,000 for each additional district the superintendent oversees and an additional $2,500 if the district includes at least one high school; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal restricts a duly elected Board of Education from increasing a superintendent’s base pay above the mandated cap; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would disallow renewal of a contract for an existing superintendent with a compensation package above the mandated cap and requires that the compensation in the new contract conform to the mandated salary cap; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would allow the duly elected Board of Education to provide a non-pensionable, individual year merit stipend awarded on the basis of the school district’s year-to-year progress relative to specific performance metrics of student learning defined by the state; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would require the New Jersey Department of Education to provide the duly elected Board of Education with a list of state-approved quantitative and qualitative merit criteria; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would permit the duly elected Board of Education to add one district-requested merit criterion to the NJDOE list and have the district-requested merit criterion approved by the Executive County Superintendent; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would allow the duly elected Board of Education to choose 3 quantitative and 2 qualitative merit criteria from the state approved list; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would require the Executive County Superintendent to assemble the quantitative and qualitative performance data that forms the basis of a superintendent’s performance evaluation relative to the state approved merit criteria; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal prescribes the amount of the non-pensionable merit stipend to be 3.33% of base salary for each quantitative performance criterion achieved and 2.5% of base salary for each qualitative performance criterion achieved in a given year; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal arbitrarily compared and set the compensation of career educators to that of his statutory elected official’s salary;
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal has no provision for higher cost of living expenses in different areas of the state;
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would impact 70% of New Jersey superintendents whose current salaries are above the proposed salary caps; therefore
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education opposes Governor Christie’s proposal to cap superintendent salaries; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education objects to the state’s interference in contract negotiations between the duly elected Board of Education and the superintendent; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education objects to the state defining the quantitative and qualitative merit criteria to be used to evaluate the superintendent’s performance; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education believes that the superintendent’s compensation and merit increase should be based on achievement of district and superintendent goals defined by the Board of Education; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the administrative and supervisory tasks required of a superintendent to run an effective and efficient school district are not to be undervalued by the state; and be it further
RESOLVED, that with dwindling resources, reduced state aid, and restrictive tax and expenditure limits, the job of the superintendent to manage the budget, supervise staff, oversee the instructional program, ensure compliance with state and federal mandates, and focus efforts on continued improvement and high student achievement requires a skilled administrator whose salary is appropriately determined based on his/her education, experience, skill, and goal attainment, not on the number of students in the district or a state approved list of performance criteria; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education duly elected by the voters in Ridgewood has the duty and responsibility to negotiate a fair and reasonable contract and set the compensation for our Superintendent of Schools; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this resolution be sent to Governor Christopher Christie, Commissioner of Education Bret Schundler Senate President Stephen Sweeney, Assembly Speaker Sheila Oliver, State Senator Kevin O’Toole, Assemblyman David Russo, and Assemblyman Scott Rumana; and be it further
RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Garden State Coalition of Schools, Dollar$ and Sense, the Bergen County Association of School Administrators, the New Jersey Association of School Administrators, the New Jersey Association of School Business Officials, and the New Jersey School Boards Association.
Here is the text of the resolution:
RESOLUTION OF THE RIDGEWOOD BOARD OF EDUCATION
RIDGEWOOD, NEW JERSEY
Superintendent Salary Cap
WHEREAS, on July 15, 2010, Governor Christopher Christie announced a reform proposal to cap school superintendents’ base pay; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie proposed that the capped salary be based on a sliding scale determined by the state; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal based the maximum amount of the capped salary for a superintendent on the number of students enrolled in the district; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal allows for an increment of $5,000 for each additional district the superintendent oversees and an additional $2,500 if the district includes at least one high school; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal restricts a duly elected Board of Education from increasing a superintendent’s base pay above the mandated cap; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would disallow renewal of a contract for an existing superintendent with a compensation package above the mandated cap and requires that the compensation in the new contract conform to the mandated salary cap; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would allow the duly elected Board of Education to provide a non-pensionable, individual year merit stipend awarded on the basis of the school district’s year-to-year progress relative to specific performance metrics of student learning defined by the state; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would require the New Jersey Department of Education to provide the duly elected Board of Education with a list of state-approved quantitative and qualitative merit criteria; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would permit the duly elected Board of Education to add one district-requested merit criterion to the NJDOE list and have the district-requested merit criterion approved by the Executive County Superintendent; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would allow the duly elected Board of Education to choose 3 quantitative and 2 qualitative merit criteria from the state approved list; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would require the Executive County Superintendent to assemble the quantitative and qualitative performance data that forms the basis of a superintendent’s performance evaluation relative to the state approved merit criteria; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal prescribes the amount of the non-pensionable merit stipend to be 3.33% of base salary for each quantitative performance criterion achieved and 2.5% of base salary for each qualitative performance criterion achieved in a given year; and
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal arbitrarily compared and set the compensation of career educators to that of his statutory elected official’s salary;
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal has no provision for higher cost of living expenses in different areas of the state;
WHEREAS, Governor Christie’s proposal would impact 70% of New Jersey superintendents whose current salaries are above the proposed salary caps; therefore
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education opposes Governor Christie’s proposal to cap superintendent salaries; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education objects to the state’s interference in contract negotiations between the duly elected Board of Education and the superintendent; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education objects to the state defining the quantitative and qualitative merit criteria to be used to evaluate the superintendent’s performance; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education believes that the superintendent’s compensation and merit increase should be based on achievement of district and superintendent goals defined by the Board of Education; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the administrative and supervisory tasks required of a superintendent to run an effective and efficient school district are not to be undervalued by the state; and be it further
RESOLVED, that with dwindling resources, reduced state aid, and restrictive tax and expenditure limits, the job of the superintendent to manage the budget, supervise staff, oversee the instructional program, ensure compliance with state and federal mandates, and focus efforts on continued improvement and high student achievement requires a skilled administrator whose salary is appropriately determined based on his/her education, experience, skill, and goal attainment, not on the number of students in the district or a state approved list of performance criteria; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Ridgewood Board of Education duly elected by the voters in Ridgewood has the duty and responsibility to negotiate a fair and reasonable contract and set the compensation for our Superintendent of Schools; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this resolution be sent to Governor Christopher Christie, Commissioner of Education Bret Schundler Senate President Stephen Sweeney, Assembly Speaker Sheila Oliver, State Senator Kevin O’Toole, Assemblyman David Russo, and Assemblyman Scott Rumana; and be it further
RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Garden State Coalition of Schools, Dollar$ and Sense, the Bergen County Association of School Administrators, the New Jersey Association of School Administrators, the New Jersey Association of School Business Officials, and the New Jersey School Boards Association.
Monday, July 19, 2010
Who says summer meetings are quiet?
Tonight's meeting of the Board of Education was for the most part a quiet affair, as meetings during the summer usually are. Dr. Fishbein updated us on referendum construction projects, which are rolling along. Big work starting at Hawes...Stevens Field is dug and draining is being installed...roofing projects all over the place. So far, so good. Our construction management company, Epic, is doing a great job of overseeing things and updating the administration and Facilities Committee.
We actually conducted some important business at tonight's meeting:
The Board passed a resolution opposing Governor Christie's proposal to cap school superintendents' salaries. We made some revisions during the meeting, so when the revised version is available in a day or so, I'll post it here.
The Board also approved going forward with a plan to install lights at the RHS Stadium and Stevens Fields, thanks to a financial partnership with many of the community sports programs, and high school parent booster groups. If you recall, during the referendum discussion last Fall, we talked about the need and desire for lights, but we wanted to wait and see if community sports groups were able to contribute to the funding. Over the past few weeks, a few remarkable things happened to lead to tonight's decision: first, the District solicited bids for the best, high-tech lights out there -- Musco lights are efficient and so well-targeted that there is no "light spill" just a few feet from the field. Next, the bids came in much lower than expected, and one contractor's prices were about $300,000 lower than the next bidder. Next, several youth sports groups and high school booster groups committed to funding over half the total cost, and Dr. Fishbein outlined a plan for the District the fund the remainder through a combination of donations to the District in exchange for "naming rights" of various facilities, through annual savings of approx. $10,000 in water expenses that will not be needed to water the turf fields, and, if necessary, with money saved in referendum project costs coming in much lower than projected.
Basically, the total cost of the lights is roughly $500,000 and it's a 5-year lease-purchase program. The sports groups will fund 100% of the installation -- $106,000 -- in the first year, then in years 2 through 5, the sports groups will fund $40,000 per year, and the BOE will fund $65,000. We could raise all the remaining funds through additional donations. It's definitely within reach. In any event, we'll have access to the leftover referendum funds in years 4-5 (that's when the projects will be complete), so the only "unknown" is our portion for years 2-3, which is about $130,000 (or $110,000 if you deduct the money we're saving by not watering the fields). There are already potential corporate donors "in the pipeline," who are eager to make donations in exchange for naming rights to fields or other facilities. (The Board already has a policy for naming rights...it is currently being updated.)
I'm really proud that we were able to work together, in partnership with the community, to make this happen. The arrangement is similar to what happened in the construction of Maple Field, when the sports groups worked with the Village and were so successful in their fundraising, that they were able to fulfill their financial commitment early.
Also at tonight's meeting, we approved a change to the school calendar for this year, 2010-11. As part of our budget cuts for this year, we eliminated paying teachers for extra time to conduct parent conferences outside of school hours. Instead, elementary schools will hold a half-day session on Election Day November 2, with teachers holding parent conferences in the afternoon. Additionally, all schools grade K-12 will be closed on November 3. On that day, grade K-5 teachers will conduct conferences, and grades 6-12 will do professional development. This will flow into the Teacher Convention Days, which are November 4 and 5.
The next Board of Ed meeting will be August 30. This will be our annual "Retreat," where we will set goals for the 2010-11 school year, and discuss our evaluation of our operations and effectiveness.
We actually conducted some important business at tonight's meeting:
The Board passed a resolution opposing Governor Christie's proposal to cap school superintendents' salaries. We made some revisions during the meeting, so when the revised version is available in a day or so, I'll post it here.
The Board also approved going forward with a plan to install lights at the RHS Stadium and Stevens Fields, thanks to a financial partnership with many of the community sports programs, and high school parent booster groups. If you recall, during the referendum discussion last Fall, we talked about the need and desire for lights, but we wanted to wait and see if community sports groups were able to contribute to the funding. Over the past few weeks, a few remarkable things happened to lead to tonight's decision: first, the District solicited bids for the best, high-tech lights out there -- Musco lights are efficient and so well-targeted that there is no "light spill" just a few feet from the field. Next, the bids came in much lower than expected, and one contractor's prices were about $300,000 lower than the next bidder. Next, several youth sports groups and high school booster groups committed to funding over half the total cost, and Dr. Fishbein outlined a plan for the District the fund the remainder through a combination of donations to the District in exchange for "naming rights" of various facilities, through annual savings of approx. $10,000 in water expenses that will not be needed to water the turf fields, and, if necessary, with money saved in referendum project costs coming in much lower than projected.
Basically, the total cost of the lights is roughly $500,000 and it's a 5-year lease-purchase program. The sports groups will fund 100% of the installation -- $106,000 -- in the first year, then in years 2 through 5, the sports groups will fund $40,000 per year, and the BOE will fund $65,000. We could raise all the remaining funds through additional donations. It's definitely within reach. In any event, we'll have access to the leftover referendum funds in years 4-5 (that's when the projects will be complete), so the only "unknown" is our portion for years 2-3, which is about $130,000 (or $110,000 if you deduct the money we're saving by not watering the fields). There are already potential corporate donors "in the pipeline," who are eager to make donations in exchange for naming rights to fields or other facilities. (The Board already has a policy for naming rights...it is currently being updated.)
I'm really proud that we were able to work together, in partnership with the community, to make this happen. The arrangement is similar to what happened in the construction of Maple Field, when the sports groups worked with the Village and were so successful in their fundraising, that they were able to fulfill their financial commitment early.
Also at tonight's meeting, we approved a change to the school calendar for this year, 2010-11. As part of our budget cuts for this year, we eliminated paying teachers for extra time to conduct parent conferences outside of school hours. Instead, elementary schools will hold a half-day session on Election Day November 2, with teachers holding parent conferences in the afternoon. Additionally, all schools grade K-12 will be closed on November 3. On that day, grade K-5 teachers will conduct conferences, and grades 6-12 will do professional development. This will flow into the Teacher Convention Days, which are November 4 and 5.
The next Board of Ed meeting will be August 30. This will be our annual "Retreat," where we will set goals for the 2010-11 school year, and discuss our evaluation of our operations and effectiveness.
Friday, July 16, 2010
What's behind Gov. Christie's cap on superintendent's salaries?
Reprinting an interesting post from NJ Left Behind:
What’s behind Gov. Christie’s surprise announcement that he is capping school superintendent salaries? Isn't this sort of un-Republican? What happened to the free market economy? Is it a sort of shooting-fish-in-a-barrel move, a free ride fueled by public animosity towards school taxes or the occasional exorbitant salary? Is it a set-up for capping teacher salaries or installing statewide contracts? Is Christie trying to get some love from Jersey City, where citizens are fighting back against a mishandled $268,000 annual superintendent contract? Is the heat getting to him?
A few facts to throw out there: first, superintendent salaries are a tiny piece of school costs. From New Jersey School Boards Association’s press release yesterday:
The department’s National Center for Education Statistics indicates that New Jersey directs 9.5 percent of public school expenditures toward central-office and school-level administration, as compared to a nationwide average of 10.8 percent. According to this report, New Jersey administrative spending is lower than that of 42 other states. At the same time, New Jersey’s spending on instruction and student support services (71.9% of total expenditures) is higher than the nationwide average.
Secondly, one reason for high salaries, to whatever degree they’re high, is because school superintendents don’t get tenure. (A blog called Dr. Petrosino's Education Project argues that the DOE should reinstate tenure to balance out newly-cropped salaries.) Thirdly, the cap of $175,000, except for the 16 districts with more than 10,000 students, will encourage some unknown number of superintendents to go to Pennsylvania or New York or Delaware, which remain capless. Not so good for maintaining quality. See what happens, Gov. Christie, when you go all non-Republican on us? (Read Bruce Baker’s post at SchoolFinance101, specifically his chart of NY superintendent salaries which are almost all above $175K, at least in southern NY., though his larger point that the cap is arbitrary is rebutted by John Mooney at NJ Spotlight in the comment section of today’s column, also well-worth reading.)
Of course the cap will also wreak havoc with administrators – supervisors, principals, directors -- further down the food chain, some of whom get more than $175,000. (The slick comparison to Christie’s salary, also $175K, by the way, is a canard: not too many superintendents we know are contemplating higher office or big book deals in a couple of years. Superintendency is typically the last stop.)
In effect, Christie’s plan takes school superintendents out of the marketplace and places them on a pay grade on the civil service scale. Next to come is business administrators and assistant superintendents, according to Comm. Schundler. Are teacher salaries the endgame?
What’s behind Gov. Christie’s surprise announcement that he is capping school superintendent salaries? Isn't this sort of un-Republican? What happened to the free market economy? Is it a sort of shooting-fish-in-a-barrel move, a free ride fueled by public animosity towards school taxes or the occasional exorbitant salary? Is it a set-up for capping teacher salaries or installing statewide contracts? Is Christie trying to get some love from Jersey City, where citizens are fighting back against a mishandled $268,000 annual superintendent contract? Is the heat getting to him?
A few facts to throw out there: first, superintendent salaries are a tiny piece of school costs. From New Jersey School Boards Association’s press release yesterday:
The department’s National Center for Education Statistics indicates that New Jersey directs 9.5 percent of public school expenditures toward central-office and school-level administration, as compared to a nationwide average of 10.8 percent. According to this report, New Jersey administrative spending is lower than that of 42 other states. At the same time, New Jersey’s spending on instruction and student support services (71.9% of total expenditures) is higher than the nationwide average.
Secondly, one reason for high salaries, to whatever degree they’re high, is because school superintendents don’t get tenure. (A blog called Dr. Petrosino's Education Project argues that the DOE should reinstate tenure to balance out newly-cropped salaries.) Thirdly, the cap of $175,000, except for the 16 districts with more than 10,000 students, will encourage some unknown number of superintendents to go to Pennsylvania or New York or Delaware, which remain capless. Not so good for maintaining quality. See what happens, Gov. Christie, when you go all non-Republican on us? (Read Bruce Baker’s post at SchoolFinance101, specifically his chart of NY superintendent salaries which are almost all above $175K, at least in southern NY., though his larger point that the cap is arbitrary is rebutted by John Mooney at NJ Spotlight in the comment section of today’s column, also well-worth reading.)
Of course the cap will also wreak havoc with administrators – supervisors, principals, directors -- further down the food chain, some of whom get more than $175,000. (The slick comparison to Christie’s salary, also $175K, by the way, is a canard: not too many superintendents we know are contemplating higher office or big book deals in a couple of years. Superintendency is typically the last stop.)
In effect, Christie’s plan takes school superintendents out of the marketplace and places them on a pay grade on the civil service scale. Next to come is business administrators and assistant superintendents, according to Comm. Schundler. Are teacher salaries the endgame?
Monday, July 12, 2010
They are busy in Trenton.
As if creating a budget and dealing with the state's deficit weren't enough, you'll be happy to know that our state legislators are also busy crafting other vital legislation. Here's a sample of recent bills:
A-3140 Spencer (D-29); Wagner (D-38) Requires boards of education to calculate body mass index for students in first, fourth, seventh, and tenth grades.
Oh, boy, for all those parents who feel schools intrude too far into the personal lives or home lives of students, how is this? Under this bill, we'd be calculating weight and body fat and, presumably, tracking this info over time.
A-444/S-295 Spencer (D-29), Caputo (D-28), Quijano (D-20), Rodriguez (D-33) Requires school board members to undergo criminal history background checks, and it would disqualify members convicted of any crime that would disqualify a person from working in a public school.
OK, this isn't so bad, I suppose. The NJ School Boards Association already supports disclosure of past criminal convictions by current and prospective school board members. I think it's a little annoying that the school board member would be required to pay the cost of the background check...and I certainly agree with critics who wonder why background checks wouldn't be required of charter school trustees -- or all elected officials?
A-1019/S-438 Spencer (D-29), Caputo (D-28), Quijano (D-20), Rodriguez (D-33) (passed the Assembly on June 28 by a 74-2-1 vote, and now in the Senate Education Committee) would require background checks of all school volunteers.
Yikes, can you imagine? Mandatory background checks for everyone who works at an HSA book fair, who serves cupcakes at the faculty breakfast, who checks-in books at the library, or who reads a story to kindergartners? And, of course, the cost of the fingerprinting, etc., would be borne by the volunteer! This would be difficult to implement, at best, and the hassle factor alone would definitely keep people from volunteering. Silly, if you ask me.
A-3140 Spencer (D-29); Wagner (D-38) Requires boards of education to calculate body mass index for students in first, fourth, seventh, and tenth grades.
Oh, boy, for all those parents who feel schools intrude too far into the personal lives or home lives of students, how is this? Under this bill, we'd be calculating weight and body fat and, presumably, tracking this info over time.
A-444/S-295 Spencer (D-29), Caputo (D-28), Quijano (D-20), Rodriguez (D-33) Requires school board members to undergo criminal history background checks, and it would disqualify members convicted of any crime that would disqualify a person from working in a public school.
OK, this isn't so bad, I suppose. The NJ School Boards Association already supports disclosure of past criminal convictions by current and prospective school board members. I think it's a little annoying that the school board member would be required to pay the cost of the background check...and I certainly agree with critics who wonder why background checks wouldn't be required of charter school trustees -- or all elected officials?
A-1019/S-438 Spencer (D-29), Caputo (D-28), Quijano (D-20), Rodriguez (D-33) (passed the Assembly on June 28 by a 74-2-1 vote, and now in the Senate Education Committee) would require background checks of all school volunteers.
Yikes, can you imagine? Mandatory background checks for everyone who works at an HSA book fair, who serves cupcakes at the faculty breakfast, who checks-in books at the library, or who reads a story to kindergartners? And, of course, the cost of the fingerprinting, etc., would be borne by the volunteer! This would be difficult to implement, at best, and the hassle factor alone would definitely keep people from volunteering. Silly, if you ask me.
Tuesday, July 6, 2010
Can a public district convert to a charter or private district and leave Trenton's rules behind?
There was a story in the Star-Ledger this weekend about the Glen Ridge district considering converting to charter schools or private schools.
According to the story:
Faced with burdensome mandates and diminishing returns from Trenton, one of the state’s top public school districts is considering a path that could make it the first to effectively secede from New Jersey’s public education system.
The Glen Ridge school board will enter largely uncharted waters when it gathers at a retreat this month to discuss converting some or all of the four schools in the 1,932-student district to charter or private schools.
In a community where the average property tax bill tops $16,000, the idea of becoming a breakaway district emerged as word spread that Glen Ridge’s already small portion of state aid would vanish and that New Jersey might embrace a new cap limit to tax increases in order to encourage school districts to merge.
Click here for the full Star-Ledger story.
Sounds sort of lovely, doesn't it? Just leave Trenton behind, do things ourselves, nobody telling us what to do, nobody taking away our funds at the last minute. I bet the sun shines a little brighter and the birds sing a little sweeter, too...
Sorry, don't mean to be cynical, but I'm not super-optimistic about this. First of all, the idea that we could secede because we get "nothing" from the state isn't accurate. Sure, our regular aid was cut 100% for 2010-11. But the state does provide other aid to Ridgewood, in the form of "extraordinary aid" to help with special education costs. I don't have the exact amount at hand, but I'm fairly certain we would miss it if it were gone. Second, the state makes the employer contribution to teachers' pensions. OK, OK, the state is supposed to make the employer contribution..the fact that they have not been doing so recently is a minor detail right? You can bet that if we became responsible for making those contributions, Trenton would be all over us with fines and whatnot if we didn't pay-up on time.
Another thing to consider: I'm not sure, but I think it's true that if a school or district were to do convert to private, they would be required to turn over all property to the state.
So the question Glen Ridge's BOE will be considering is if the savings achieved by removing Trenton's rules and regs are enough to make up for the loss of extraordinary aid and the obligation to make pension contributions.
I certainly understand the appeal of "secession." I'll be watching what develops in Glen Ridge.
Small world note: Glen Ridge's current superintendent is John Mucciolo, former RHS principal. And our superintedent, Dan Fishbein, was superintendent in Glen Ridge before he came to Ridgewood.
According to the story:
Faced with burdensome mandates and diminishing returns from Trenton, one of the state’s top public school districts is considering a path that could make it the first to effectively secede from New Jersey’s public education system.
The Glen Ridge school board will enter largely uncharted waters when it gathers at a retreat this month to discuss converting some or all of the four schools in the 1,932-student district to charter or private schools.
In a community where the average property tax bill tops $16,000, the idea of becoming a breakaway district emerged as word spread that Glen Ridge’s already small portion of state aid would vanish and that New Jersey might embrace a new cap limit to tax increases in order to encourage school districts to merge.
Click here for the full Star-Ledger story.
Sounds sort of lovely, doesn't it? Just leave Trenton behind, do things ourselves, nobody telling us what to do, nobody taking away our funds at the last minute. I bet the sun shines a little brighter and the birds sing a little sweeter, too...
Sorry, don't mean to be cynical, but I'm not super-optimistic about this. First of all, the idea that we could secede because we get "nothing" from the state isn't accurate. Sure, our regular aid was cut 100% for 2010-11. But the state does provide other aid to Ridgewood, in the form of "extraordinary aid" to help with special education costs. I don't have the exact amount at hand, but I'm fairly certain we would miss it if it were gone. Second, the state makes the employer contribution to teachers' pensions. OK, OK, the state is supposed to make the employer contribution..the fact that they have not been doing so recently is a minor detail right? You can bet that if we became responsible for making those contributions, Trenton would be all over us with fines and whatnot if we didn't pay-up on time.
Another thing to consider: I'm not sure, but I think it's true that if a school or district were to do convert to private, they would be required to turn over all property to the state.
So the question Glen Ridge's BOE will be considering is if the savings achieved by removing Trenton's rules and regs are enough to make up for the loss of extraordinary aid and the obligation to make pension contributions.
I certainly understand the appeal of "secession." I'll be watching what develops in Glen Ridge.
Small world note: Glen Ridge's current superintendent is John Mucciolo, former RHS principal. And our superintedent, Dan Fishbein, was superintendent in Glen Ridge before he came to Ridgewood.
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Best explanation I've read for NJ's school financing/tax mess.
The following appeared in the Wall Street Journal yesterday and it is one of the most concise and informative explanations I've seen for New Jersey's school funding mess -- and how we got here.
Click here to read it on its source site.
New Jersey's Suburban Tax Blues
By PAUL MULSHINE
Newark, N.J.
With Rush Limbaugh fawning over him on talk radio and Fred Barnes comparing him to Ronald Reagan, New Jersey Republican Gov. Chris Christie is being hailed a conservative hero. But conservatives here in the Garden State aren't sold. Mr. Christie has been in office just a few months and is kindling comparisons not to President Reagan, but to the last governor named Christie.
In 1993 Christie Whitman, like Chris Christie in 2009, won the Republican nomination for governor by tacking to the right in the primary. In the general election she promised to cut income taxes in every tax bracket and implement an initiative-and-referendum process to give voters direct input on public policies. Mr. Christie made the same promises last fall.
But here the comparison gets interesting. Ms. Whitman actually cut state income taxes across the board—before losing favor with conservatives thanks to her spending policies and judicial picks. But Mr. Christie hasn't mentioned cutting income taxes since election night. He's blasted runaway spending, for which he's received due credit. Yet his proposed state budget all but guarantees suburban homeowners a property-tax hike this year.
The most important political issue in New Jersey—the one that drives debates about income taxes, property taxes, and local government power—is public education. The core of the problem is a string of state Supreme Court decisions, the most sweeping of which were issued by judges Ms. Whitman put on the court.
These rulings have directed an ever larger share of state income taxes to a handful of urban school districts. Suburban homeowners pay income taxes to support the urban schools while also paying some of the highest property taxes in the country to support local schools.
Getting a better break for the suburbs has been Republicans' goal since the state income tax was instituted in 1976. And they were optimistic when Gov. Christie appointed Bret Schundler, a former Jersey City mayor and a strong supporter of school choice, as the state's commissioner of education. But Mr. Schundler shocked fellow Republicans by proposing a new education funding formula that tilts spending further in favor of cities.
In legislative hearings, Mr. Schundler said the formula had been fashioned to comply with past rulings of the state Supreme Court. The first such ruling came in 1976, when the court shut down the state's schools to demand that the state send more money to the cities. That crisis spurred then-Gov. Brendan Byrne, a Democrat, to push the legislature to create the state's income tax. He promised the money from the income tax would be used to cut property taxes statewide.
And it did—until 1985. That year the State Supreme Court, claiming that the constitution required the state to spend more money on schools in poorer communities, ordered New Jersey to pump large sums into what turned out to be 31 districts now known as the Abbott districts. Four years ago, the Abbott districts were receiving 56% of the income tax money that had been meant to relieve local property taxes, while the suburban districts got 44%. Under Mr. Christie's budget for next year, that 56% rises to 60%.
The Abbott districts get about $4.8 billion in aid, while the 500-plus other districts must split up $3.2 billion. Thus Asbury Park will receive $28,232 per-pupil from the state next year while Mendham, the governor's hometown, will get $2.32 per pupil.
The Christie formula zeroed out state aid to 59 towns, many of which gave him the largest pluralities in last year's elections. Many such towns send tens of millions in income taxes to Trenton, and also face endless property tax hikes to fund their own schools. West Orange resident Adam Kraemer, who spoke at an antitax rally in his North Jersey town recently, owns a four-bedroom home on a small lot and pays $25,972 a year in property taxes. Mr. Kraemer said he expects his tax bill to hit $27,600 under Mr. Christie's budget.
Mr. Christie has a habit of evading questions about what he would do for homeowners like Mr. Kraemer. So far, the governor has done little more than endorse a promise also made by Ms. Whitman: a proposal to create voucher programs. The governor argues that vouchers and charter schools would alleviate some of the financial pressure the Abbott districts place on the rest of the state. Fine, but in the meantime New Jersey homeowners are crying out for the sort of comprehensive reform Californians got under Proposition 13, the 1978 ballot measure that addressed a similar court takeover of school funding.
Mr. Christie's fortunes will rise and fall depending on whether he can take back control of school funding from the courts and give suburban towns an equal share of state aid. But if taxes continue to rise, his prospects will fall—no matter how much he pleases commentators who don't pay Jersey property taxes.
Mr. Mulshine is a columnist for the Newark Star Ledger.
Click here to read it on its source site.
New Jersey's Suburban Tax Blues
By PAUL MULSHINE
Newark, N.J.
With Rush Limbaugh fawning over him on talk radio and Fred Barnes comparing him to Ronald Reagan, New Jersey Republican Gov. Chris Christie is being hailed a conservative hero. But conservatives here in the Garden State aren't sold. Mr. Christie has been in office just a few months and is kindling comparisons not to President Reagan, but to the last governor named Christie.
In 1993 Christie Whitman, like Chris Christie in 2009, won the Republican nomination for governor by tacking to the right in the primary. In the general election she promised to cut income taxes in every tax bracket and implement an initiative-and-referendum process to give voters direct input on public policies. Mr. Christie made the same promises last fall.
But here the comparison gets interesting. Ms. Whitman actually cut state income taxes across the board—before losing favor with conservatives thanks to her spending policies and judicial picks. But Mr. Christie hasn't mentioned cutting income taxes since election night. He's blasted runaway spending, for which he's received due credit. Yet his proposed state budget all but guarantees suburban homeowners a property-tax hike this year.
The most important political issue in New Jersey—the one that drives debates about income taxes, property taxes, and local government power—is public education. The core of the problem is a string of state Supreme Court decisions, the most sweeping of which were issued by judges Ms. Whitman put on the court.
These rulings have directed an ever larger share of state income taxes to a handful of urban school districts. Suburban homeowners pay income taxes to support the urban schools while also paying some of the highest property taxes in the country to support local schools.
Getting a better break for the suburbs has been Republicans' goal since the state income tax was instituted in 1976. And they were optimistic when Gov. Christie appointed Bret Schundler, a former Jersey City mayor and a strong supporter of school choice, as the state's commissioner of education. But Mr. Schundler shocked fellow Republicans by proposing a new education funding formula that tilts spending further in favor of cities.
In legislative hearings, Mr. Schundler said the formula had been fashioned to comply with past rulings of the state Supreme Court. The first such ruling came in 1976, when the court shut down the state's schools to demand that the state send more money to the cities. That crisis spurred then-Gov. Brendan Byrne, a Democrat, to push the legislature to create the state's income tax. He promised the money from the income tax would be used to cut property taxes statewide.
And it did—until 1985. That year the State Supreme Court, claiming that the constitution required the state to spend more money on schools in poorer communities, ordered New Jersey to pump large sums into what turned out to be 31 districts now known as the Abbott districts. Four years ago, the Abbott districts were receiving 56% of the income tax money that had been meant to relieve local property taxes, while the suburban districts got 44%. Under Mr. Christie's budget for next year, that 56% rises to 60%.
The Abbott districts get about $4.8 billion in aid, while the 500-plus other districts must split up $3.2 billion. Thus Asbury Park will receive $28,232 per-pupil from the state next year while Mendham, the governor's hometown, will get $2.32 per pupil.
The Christie formula zeroed out state aid to 59 towns, many of which gave him the largest pluralities in last year's elections. Many such towns send tens of millions in income taxes to Trenton, and also face endless property tax hikes to fund their own schools. West Orange resident Adam Kraemer, who spoke at an antitax rally in his North Jersey town recently, owns a four-bedroom home on a small lot and pays $25,972 a year in property taxes. Mr. Kraemer said he expects his tax bill to hit $27,600 under Mr. Christie's budget.
Mr. Christie has a habit of evading questions about what he would do for homeowners like Mr. Kraemer. So far, the governor has done little more than endorse a promise also made by Ms. Whitman: a proposal to create voucher programs. The governor argues that vouchers and charter schools would alleviate some of the financial pressure the Abbott districts place on the rest of the state. Fine, but in the meantime New Jersey homeowners are crying out for the sort of comprehensive reform Californians got under Proposition 13, the 1978 ballot measure that addressed a similar court takeover of school funding.
Mr. Christie's fortunes will rise and fall depending on whether he can take back control of school funding from the courts and give suburban towns an equal share of state aid. But if taxes continue to rise, his prospects will fall—no matter how much he pleases commentators who don't pay Jersey property taxes.
Mr. Mulshine is a columnist for the Newark Star Ledger.
Saturday, April 17, 2010
At least Christie will honor our referendum construction grants.
From the department of "What, me worry?"
Press release from the New Jersey Association of School Business Officials, 4/17/10:
GOVERNOR CHRIS CHRISTIE ANNOUNCES SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION FUNDING
Trenton, NJ -- Governor Christie announced today that schools construction projects in school districts across New Jersey will soon begin to receive funding for projects following approval for the sale of $500 million in new bonds by the Board of Directors for the New Jersey Economic Development Authority.
The New Jersey Schools Development Authority (SDA) will use proceeds from the bonds toward school facilities projects in SDA Districts and continue the SDA grant program for Regular Operating Districts (RODs). These state-funded ROD grants represent at least 40 percent of costs for projects in non-Abbott districts, addressing health and safety issues, student overcrowding and other critical needs. Local districts fund the remainder.
"It is important for these school projects to move forward with state financial support," said Governor Christie. "My administration is committed to providing exemplary educational facilities for our students in all school districts across New Jersey. The sale of these bonds is a fiscally responsible way to continue to address the school-construction needs of New Jersey's public schools."
Press release from the New Jersey Association of School Business Officials, 4/17/10:
GOVERNOR CHRIS CHRISTIE ANNOUNCES SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION FUNDING
Trenton, NJ -- Governor Christie announced today that schools construction projects in school districts across New Jersey will soon begin to receive funding for projects following approval for the sale of $500 million in new bonds by the Board of Directors for the New Jersey Economic Development Authority.
The New Jersey Schools Development Authority (SDA) will use proceeds from the bonds toward school facilities projects in SDA Districts and continue the SDA grant program for Regular Operating Districts (RODs). These state-funded ROD grants represent at least 40 percent of costs for projects in non-Abbott districts, addressing health and safety issues, student overcrowding and other critical needs. Local districts fund the remainder.
"It is important for these school projects to move forward with state financial support," said Governor Christie. "My administration is committed to providing exemplary educational facilities for our students in all school districts across New Jersey. The sale of these bonds is a fiscally responsible way to continue to address the school-construction needs of New Jersey's public schools."
Dollars & Sense will testify before Assembly budget committee on Monday.
Reprinted from Dollars & Sense Advocacy email 4/16/10.
The Office of Legislative Services recently released their analysis of the proposed budget. It didn't offer a positive assessment regarding the impact on public education.
"The proposed FY 2011 budget reduces direct aid to schools districts by $1.09 billion. The Executive Branch has suggested that school districts can cope with the recommended decrease in aid by entering agreements with personnel to forego scheduled salary increases and contribute 1.5 percent of their salaries to the cost of health insurance premiums."
The paragraph concludes saying, "In summary, it is estimated that if all school districts took these actions, they would still have to address a budget shortfall of at least $849.3 million (77.9% of the proposed aid reduction)."
It also said, "The proposed State aid calculation departs significantly from the funding provisions of the School Funding Reform Act (SFRA) of 2008." We remember very well what the State Supreme Court's opinion said. Our organization took great exception to the SFRA, but at least it was an attempt to deliver funding for every child. Proposed language changes alter the viability of the formula. For all of that work and all of those efforts to be cast aside is unacceptable. It is clearly an invitation for the litigation we can expect in the near future.
Looking ahead, the cost to recover from the proposed budget cuts is much too high. Some of the proposed cuts carry an after the fact cost that increases exponentially. The recent report of AHSA (the current alternate high school exit exam) scores illustrates the point. Of the 10,000 students who took the alternate assessment, the passing rates were only 10% in language arts and 34% in mathematics. Approximately 7000 students are going to need remedial help if they are to graduate. These students' needs aren't going to disappear. Seriously reducing programs, like summer school, will lead to an increase in our high school dropout rate. It's bad business and we can't afford it.
Monday, April 19th, Dollar$ & Sense Education Advocacy will testify before the Assembly Budget Committee. Among the points we hope to make are the following:
1) The issues at hand aren't about the Governor or the NJEA. Nobody, on either side of any issue, responds well to a bully. A governor bully and a union bully both do a disservice to those they serve. The point is, good ideas and necessary reforms are often lost when poorly presented.
2) At a recent forum, Senator Gordon said. "We can't solve 15 to 20 years of problems with one budget." This simple truth must be clear to everybody.
3) The issues we face aren't strictly fiscal. We have to realize that social, educational, and fiscal perspectives must all be considered together. The proposed approach looks only to fiscal, and only the upfront costs at that. The cost to recover from certain cuts is well beyond the value in savings. That is where the proposed budget fails. "Penny wise and pound foolish" is shortsighted, socially deficient, educationally devastating, and fiscally irresponsible.
4) Chopping and slashing provides short-term relief and long term regret. The education of our children and those in need of social services or medical care are still going to need remediation or health care tomorrow. We know from vast experience that problems left for tomorrow cost more than addressing them today. If we can't do it all, we still must do the very best we can.
5) We don't fund schools efficiently. We don't distribute aid equitably. We don't tax citizens or businesses fairly and this continually is to our regret. If we can be told that everything is on the table, then all possible solutions must be on the table as well. Possible solutions are available that address the true core of our problems.
The Office of Legislative Services recently released their analysis of the proposed budget. It didn't offer a positive assessment regarding the impact on public education.
"The proposed FY 2011 budget reduces direct aid to schools districts by $1.09 billion. The Executive Branch has suggested that school districts can cope with the recommended decrease in aid by entering agreements with personnel to forego scheduled salary increases and contribute 1.5 percent of their salaries to the cost of health insurance premiums."
The paragraph concludes saying, "In summary, it is estimated that if all school districts took these actions, they would still have to address a budget shortfall of at least $849.3 million (77.9% of the proposed aid reduction)."
It also said, "The proposed State aid calculation departs significantly from the funding provisions of the School Funding Reform Act (SFRA) of 2008." We remember very well what the State Supreme Court's opinion said. Our organization took great exception to the SFRA, but at least it was an attempt to deliver funding for every child. Proposed language changes alter the viability of the formula. For all of that work and all of those efforts to be cast aside is unacceptable. It is clearly an invitation for the litigation we can expect in the near future.
Looking ahead, the cost to recover from the proposed budget cuts is much too high. Some of the proposed cuts carry an after the fact cost that increases exponentially. The recent report of AHSA (the current alternate high school exit exam) scores illustrates the point. Of the 10,000 students who took the alternate assessment, the passing rates were only 10% in language arts and 34% in mathematics. Approximately 7000 students are going to need remedial help if they are to graduate. These students' needs aren't going to disappear. Seriously reducing programs, like summer school, will lead to an increase in our high school dropout rate. It's bad business and we can't afford it.
Monday, April 19th, Dollar$ & Sense Education Advocacy will testify before the Assembly Budget Committee. Among the points we hope to make are the following:
1) The issues at hand aren't about the Governor or the NJEA. Nobody, on either side of any issue, responds well to a bully. A governor bully and a union bully both do a disservice to those they serve. The point is, good ideas and necessary reforms are often lost when poorly presented.
2) At a recent forum, Senator Gordon said. "We can't solve 15 to 20 years of problems with one budget." This simple truth must be clear to everybody.
3) The issues we face aren't strictly fiscal. We have to realize that social, educational, and fiscal perspectives must all be considered together. The proposed approach looks only to fiscal, and only the upfront costs at that. The cost to recover from certain cuts is well beyond the value in savings. That is where the proposed budget fails. "Penny wise and pound foolish" is shortsighted, socially deficient, educationally devastating, and fiscally irresponsible.
4) Chopping and slashing provides short-term relief and long term regret. The education of our children and those in need of social services or medical care are still going to need remediation or health care tomorrow. We know from vast experience that problems left for tomorrow cost more than addressing them today. If we can't do it all, we still must do the very best we can.
5) We don't fund schools efficiently. We don't distribute aid equitably. We don't tax citizens or businesses fairly and this continually is to our regret. If we can be told that everything is on the table, then all possible solutions must be on the table as well. Possible solutions are available that address the true core of our problems.
Friday, April 16, 2010
Governor Christie's latest "deal o' the day" could be devastating for Ridgewood
I'm truly sorry that every idea that Governor comes up with -- and he seems to have a new one every day -- is met by my skepticism or negative prediction. Honestly, I wish the guy would come up with something thoughtful and positive, something that shows he actually grasps the complexities of the issues and the ramifications of his sound bite education policy. I'd love to support some good, creative, non-destructive ideas.
Instead, the latest Hail Mary from Trenton is one of those over-simplified ideas that could harm our schools for years:
The governor has proposed changes to the state's pension and benefits rules that would give an incentive to teachers to retire. Under the plan, teacher retirements could jump seven-fold, with as many as 30,000 veteran educators statewide exiting before the next school year. In Ridgewood, estimates are that as many as 100 teachers could suddenly retire. While the money savings realized by replacing those higher-paid senior teachers with lower-paid new teachers could be significant, let's just think about the further ramifications:
If 100 teachers suddenly retired over the summer, Ridgewood would need to scramble to hire replacements. If 30,000 teachers retired statewide, we would find ourselves competing mightily to fill our staffing holes. And what happens when there's competition? Higher salaries...more expensive benefits...other forms of compensation or enticements to potential employees. We could find ourselves having to pay more to attract new teachers.
Another fallout -- with a seller's market created and staffing holes all over the state, we would likely see some of our remaining teachers deciding to test the waters and see if they can get a better deal somewhere else.
Then there are the effects in our classrooms. Many of our senior teachers function as either formal or informal mentors for our younger teachers. We would suffer with the loss of this experience.
Logisticallty, 100 new teachers getting up to speed, getting to know the district, the curriculum, getting to know students, parents and administrators...that's not the most smooth transition.
And, finally, what on earth is the Governor thinking in encouraging so many teachers to start drawing pensions? Can the state afford to pay out all those pensions? Considering the state has NOT funded its obligations into the pension system for 11 of the 15 years, I highly doubt the system can afford such a large outflow of cash.
I can't wait to hear what Governor Christie's idea is for today...
Instead, the latest Hail Mary from Trenton is one of those over-simplified ideas that could harm our schools for years:
The governor has proposed changes to the state's pension and benefits rules that would give an incentive to teachers to retire. Under the plan, teacher retirements could jump seven-fold, with as many as 30,000 veteran educators statewide exiting before the next school year. In Ridgewood, estimates are that as many as 100 teachers could suddenly retire. While the money savings realized by replacing those higher-paid senior teachers with lower-paid new teachers could be significant, let's just think about the further ramifications:
If 100 teachers suddenly retired over the summer, Ridgewood would need to scramble to hire replacements. If 30,000 teachers retired statewide, we would find ourselves competing mightily to fill our staffing holes. And what happens when there's competition? Higher salaries...more expensive benefits...other forms of compensation or enticements to potential employees. We could find ourselves having to pay more to attract new teachers.
Another fallout -- with a seller's market created and staffing holes all over the state, we would likely see some of our remaining teachers deciding to test the waters and see if they can get a better deal somewhere else.
Then there are the effects in our classrooms. Many of our senior teachers function as either formal or informal mentors for our younger teachers. We would suffer with the loss of this experience.
Logisticallty, 100 new teachers getting up to speed, getting to know the district, the curriculum, getting to know students, parents and administrators...that's not the most smooth transition.
And, finally, what on earth is the Governor thinking in encouraging so many teachers to start drawing pensions? Can the state afford to pay out all those pensions? Considering the state has NOT funded its obligations into the pension system for 11 of the 15 years, I highly doubt the system can afford such a large outflow of cash.
I can't wait to hear what Governor Christie's idea is for today...
Monday, April 12, 2010
Christie has either lost his mind or he really doesn't care who gets hurt in his quest to break the NJEA.
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the rabbit hole, the other side of the looking glass, the place where nothing makes sense.
I just read this headline on NJ.com:
Gov. Chris Christie urges voters to reject school districts' budgets without wage freezes for teachers.
I am speechless.
Except for this:
Please, voters of Ridgewood, use your heads and don't be swayed by what Governor Christie wants.
Christie wants to break the NJEA? OK.
Christie is playing power and politics? Whatever.
At the end of the day (sorry, I do hate that phrase), the residents of Ridgewood only owe their allegiance to one entity -- and it's not a big guy in Trenton, whether that big guy is the governor or the chairman of the NJEA. The citizens of Ridgewood answer to ourselves. And our children.
The REA should have voted to accept the concession presented by their leadership -- not because Christie told them to, but because it was the right thing to do for Ridgewood.
We need to pass the budget on April 20 because it's the right thing to do. Failure of the budget will result in further cuts to our educational programs. Failure of the budget will not teach the NJEA or REA a lesson. It will only hurt our schools.
More to come...
I just read this headline on NJ.com:
Gov. Chris Christie urges voters to reject school districts' budgets without wage freezes for teachers.
I am speechless.
Except for this:
Please, voters of Ridgewood, use your heads and don't be swayed by what Governor Christie wants.
Christie wants to break the NJEA? OK.
Christie is playing power and politics? Whatever.
At the end of the day (sorry, I do hate that phrase), the residents of Ridgewood only owe their allegiance to one entity -- and it's not a big guy in Trenton, whether that big guy is the governor or the chairman of the NJEA. The citizens of Ridgewood answer to ourselves. And our children.
The REA should have voted to accept the concession presented by their leadership -- not because Christie told them to, but because it was the right thing to do for Ridgewood.
We need to pass the budget on April 20 because it's the right thing to do. Failure of the budget will result in further cuts to our educational programs. Failure of the budget will not teach the NJEA or REA a lesson. It will only hurt our schools.
More to come...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
